When working with cedar shingles, choosing the correct fasteners is crucial to ensure the integrity and longevity of your installation. Nails and staples are the two primary options, each with its own set of advantages and considerations. In this article, we’ll provide clear and concise guidance to help you decide whether to use nails or staples for your cedar shingle project.

Nails for Cedar Shingles

Advantages:

1. Superior Holding Power: Nails offer excellent holding power due to their larger surface area. They are less likely to back out or loosen over time.

2. Traditional Aesthetic: Nails provide a traditional and rustic look that many homeowners appreciate when installing cedar shingles.

Considerations:

1. Potential Splitting: Cedar shingles are relatively soft, and using nails with a large diameter can risk splitting the wood. To avoid this, use shingle-specific nails with a slender profile and a ring or spiral shank.

2. Installation Speed: Nailing can be slower than stapling, particularly if you are working with a manual nailer.

3. Weather Exposure: Nails may create slightly larger holes, which can potentially lead to increased moisture penetration. Proper sealing and finish coats are essential.

Staples for Cedar Shingles

Advantages:

1. Speed and Efficiency: Staplers are generally faster and more efficient for cedar shingle installation, making them a preferred choice for professionals.

2. Reduced Splitting: Staples have a smaller profile and are less likely to split cedar shingles during installation.

3. Uniform Appearance: Staples create smaller holes, resulting in a more uniform appearance on the shingles.

Considerations:

1. Holding Power: While staples are efficient, they may have slightly less holding power compared to nails. This can be a concern in areas with high winds or heavy exposure to the elements.

2. Tool Requirements: Using a pneumatic or electric stapler is essential for installing cedar shingles with staples. These tools may require additional investment.

3. Code Compliance: Local building codes may dictate the use of specific fasteners. Always ensure compliance with local regulations.

Choosing the Right Fastener

The choice between nails and staples for cedar shingles depends on your specific project requirements, tools, and preferences. Here’s a general guideline:

• Use Nails: If you prefer a traditional look, are working on a small project, or want to avoid the initial investment in specialized stapling equipment.

• Use Staples: If speed and efficiency are crucial, you have access to a pneumatic or electric stapler, or you want a more uniform appearance with reduced risk of splitting.

Whichever fastener you choose, it’s essential to ensure proper fastening techniques and, if necessary, the application of sealants and finishes to protect your cedar shingles from the elements. Cedar shingles are prized for their durability and natural beauty, and choosing the right fastener will help preserve these qualities in your installation.